Have you tried this Surf Spray from Bumble and Bumble? I have used it a few times and I feel like it roughs up my thin wimpy hair just enough without it being too messy. My hair tends to get oily quickly and it is just so fine that I sometimes want to add a little texture or volume to change things up. I get that when I highlight my hair but lately I am liking my hair darker so I am not getting any texture from highlights lately. I’ve never been a big Bumble and Bumble fan but lately I’ve been trying a bunch of their products that I really like (Sunday shampoo, Coarse Curls Creme, Hair Powder Spray, Leave-in Conditioner) but I have to say I really like them now!